The Reggaeton Riddim Case: Give the Drummer Some!
I spoke with Ivan Moreno over at IPLaw360 this week about the copyright litigation that could have a major impact on reggaeton, the popular modern blend of hip-hop, Latin, and Caribbean music. Here’s the link to Ivan’s article.
In this huge lawsuit consolidating over 50 cases, Cleveland “Clevie” Browne and other plaintiffs sued more than 160 defendants for copyright infringement. Plaintiffs claim to be the original creators of he distinctive dembow rhythm that’s become a signature of reggaeton music.
They allege that some 1,800 reggaeton songs infringe Jamaican producers Steely & Clevie’s 1989 hit “Fish Market” because they made unauthorized use (either by sampling or copying) of the song’s “riddim,” which is named after Shabba Ranks’ 1990 single “Dem Bow,”
Most of the reporting focuses on the potential impact to the reggaeton genre and whether a “beat,” and more particularly, a “genre-defining” beat is or should be protectable by copyright. But to me that framing is something of a red herring that obscures a fundamental truth about copyright.
Nobody would question that a performance of an original musical composition on a melodic and harmonic instrument like guitar or piano is protectable by copyright. I also think no one would doubt that an original solo recording on a single-note instrument (e.g., sax, trumpet, flute, trombone) can be protected by copyright.
But when it comes to drums or percussion, where the harmonic and melodic elements are stripped away, our assumptions change. Many people run into a a psychological hurdle acknowledging the protectability, or even existence, of a musical composition when melody is absent from music.
But it should be an absolutely uncontroversial proposition that a rhythm-only musical composition or recording consisting of exclusively or mostly drums and/or percussion is protectable by copyright, so long as the work is original and has the requisite modicum of creativity. With the harmonic and melodic instruments, each is doing what that instrument can do; that is the same for the drum kit and percussion.
For starters, the drum kit includes several different “instruments”: bass drum, snare, cymbals, hi-hat, toms, maybe cowbell. Percussion instruments offer endless variation, e.g. tympani, timbale, tambourine, triangle, claves, etc. And, of course, the rhythmic patterns the drummer/percussionist can play also are infinitely varied, with the individual pieces playing different rhythms (usually at the same time), and different kinds of sounds, timbres, etc.
Plaintiffs try to make this case and even included a score in their summary judgment motion to show how complex the “beat” is in Fish Market:

The top half of the score shows the drum and percussion parts. Seven pieces go into creating the Fish Market “riddim”, and, aside from the hi hat and kick drum, each of the other parts is different.
This demonstrates the complexity of the “riddim” as the high and low timbale, tambourine, synth tom, hi-hat, snare, and kick drum are all playing together in particular way. Indeed, this begins to look like a musical composition, not simply a “beat” (Of course, calling it a “beat” exacerbates the above-mentioned psychological hurdle).
Whether the drum or percussion composition (the “beat”) goes on to define a genre is irrelevant to the infringement analysis. If the work is sufficiently creative and original to be protected by copyright and others copy it, that’s infringement, whether it’s a flash in the pan that immediately fades away or subsequent artists make it hugely popular and it comes to define a genre.
I said to Ivan, even though there’s no legal need, it would be nice for a court decision to acknowledge the originality and creativity of a drum/percussion composition. I have many drummer friends and colleagues, and I’m all for increased recognition of their creativity. As I often say during a session or gig, give the drummer some!












