Author: Eric Lane

Going on a Bender

Glaser Instruments is a Nashville company that makes specialized pitch benders for guitars. The bender can be in the form of a lever arm attached to the neck plate or a saddle installed under the bridge plate (both shown and explained here).

Glaser benders come in a few varieties; for the G or B string, convertible G/B strings, or you can go for broke and get yourself a double bender for both the G and B strings.

Glaser benders are protected by a family of at least seven patents, and the company filed another patent application in April that recently published as U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2024/0274104 (‘104 Application).

The original bender patent application was filed back in 2018, and Glaser filed a series of continuation applications over the last several years. A continuation application enjoys the benefit of the original patent application’s filing, or priority, date and draws from the original application’s disclosure to pursue different protection by way of newly drafted claims.

Titled “Musical instrument pitch changer and related methods,” the ‘104 Application is directed to a pitch changer system (10) having a lever assembly (12), a lever tensioning system (18), and a rotating saddle assembly.

The pitch changer system is configured to be mounted to the body of a guitar. The lever assembly has a lever (20), and applying force to move the lever (20) forces the rotating saddle assembly into rotation to elongate. That temporarily changes the pitch of one of the strings of the guitar.

You can check out several videos of the Glaser bender being used by professional guitarists on Glaser’s home page here. Sounding great!

Take Down the FAKE: Bipartisan Senate Bill Addresses Digital Replicas

A group of both Democrat and Republican senators recently introduced a bill that would establish an online takedown regime for digital replicas. A “digital replica” is a likeness of a person or the person’s voice generated by digital technology.

The No FAKES Act defines the term as follows:

a computer-generated, highly realistic electronic representation that is readily identifiable as the voice or visual likeness of an individual

Under the proposed legislation, an individual would hold the exclusive right to authorize use of his or her digital replica, i.e., for “production, publication, reproduction, display, distribution, transmission of, or otherwise making available to the public.”

There are some fair use-flavored exceptions to the exclusive right, i.e., news and public affairs, documentary/historical/biographical use, commentary/criticism/scholarship/satire/parody, and fleeting or negligible use.

A violator of the individual’s right would be liable only if he has knowledge that what he used was a digital replica and that the replica was unauthorized.

The heart of the bill is a takedown system similar to that established by the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, or DMCA, for unauthorized online use of copyrighted works.

Here, upon discovery of an unauthorized use, the digital replica rights holder would be able to submit a takedown notice to an online service provider, which must remove or disable access to the digital replica “as soon as is technically and practically feasible” after receiving the notice. So long as the service provider complies, it would have a safe harbor from liability.

The No FAKES Act was introduced by Senators Blackburn, Coons, Klobuchar, and Tillis Apparently, the Recording Industry Association of America and the actors union, as well as some AI companies, were proponents of or involved in the drafting of the bill.

Reactional is Leveling the Playing Field for Musical Composition

Reactional Music Group (Reactional) is a Swedish music tech company that provides products for generative musical composition.

Reactional recently got a patent relating to its generative music engine and delivery platform. Issued July 2, 2024, U.S. Patent No. 12,027,146 is entitled “Instrument and method for real-time music generation” (‘146 Patent).

The invention of the ‘146 Patent is designed to enable interactive musical experiences for users who might have only minimal musical training.

The virtual instrument has a real-time input device (RID) (1), which could be a touch screen or gesture, motion, or eye-tracking device, and/or vocal input systems such as a pitch detector.

The instrument contains a musical rule set unit (7) that stores rule definitions (701) including a composer input and a set of instrument properties. These are combined with a control signal (2) generated by the RID block based on the real-time input of the user/composer (3) as an individual or a network of musicians.

A pitch generator (9) creates an output signal (8) representing music and synchronizes generated tones based in time and frequency, and an audio generator (11) converts the output signal and combines it with the instrument properties into an audio signal (10).

A musical transition handler (703) manages transitions between different sections in the generated music based on musical characteristics according to user/composer input.

The instrument properties and rule definitions (701) are combined with the real-time control signal (2), resulting in note trigger signals (6) associated with time and frequency domain properties.

According to Reactional’s website, its “patented generative music engine and delivery platform open up a new era of music personalisation, a faster and more efficient method to create and prototype music for developers, and for the first time, music as an in-game purchase.”

Patent Tune Up: Play Without Play and Clip On Your Snark

If you’re a guitarist (which may describe many of you) or you play with a guitarist (which probably describes the rest of you), you know that tuning and re-tuning the guitar is a perpetual work-in-progress. Two recently published/issued patent documents relate to guitar tuner technology and design.

U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2024/0161717 (‘717 Application), published May 16, 2024 (patent applications publish 18 months after the priority application filing date) relates to a tuner for a “chordophone” instrument (read: guitar). The application is owned by Alessi Tuning Machines (Alessi).

Entitled “Tuner with the possibility of restoring the play possibly present between the involute screw and the gear wheel meshing the same,” the ‘717 Application is directed to a tuner having a mechanism for reducing play between the tuner, which the company calls “no backlash.”

Alessi’s informational web page explains the technical advantage of its patent-pending tuner as follows:

[The precision] concerns the worm screw and rotation gear of the roller barrel. The final coupling between the two parts is made in such a way as to cancel even the slightest play, so that the rotation of the roller (the string winding barrel) is as direct and immediate as possible in both directions of movement, giving the player a very real sense of direct contact with the string whilst tuning.

According to the ‘717 Application, the tuner (1) has a first small slab or plate (3) that is connected to the headstock of the guitar neck. An involute screw (5) is interposed between two shoulders (6) through which the screw (5) is connected to a second small slab (7) connected to the first small slab (3).

The screw (5) is connected by shaft (8) to a knob (9) that the guitarist grasps to rotate the screw (5).

The seats (11) and (23) act as linear guiding means forcing the slab (7) and screw (5) to translate with respect to the plate (3) so the screw (5) is forced to translate towards or away from the wheel (28) orthogonally to first and second axes so that, whenever play is undesirably present between the screw 5 and the wheel 28:

following an unscrewing of the nut 26 from the wall 17, so as to loosen the tightening of the slab 7 between the flange 21 and the plate 3, the screw 5 is translatable towards the wheel 28, in accordance with (i.e., “as required by”) the aforesaid guiding means, so as to eliminate said play, and after eliminating said play, the slab 7 is integrally reconnectable to the plate 3 by screwing the nut 26 onto the wall 17 so that the nut 26 returns to abut against the plate 3, redetermining the tightening of the slab 7 between the flange 21 and the plate 3.

U.S. Design Patent No. D1,027,021 (‘021 Patent) claims the design claims the ornamental design for a clip-on musical instrument tuner. The ‘021 Patent is assigned to Evets Corporation.

Unlike the more common utility patent, a design patent protects the ornamental or aesthetic features of a device, rather than the device’s functional features.

The commercial embodiment of the clip-on tuner claimed in the ‘021 Patent appears to be the Snark Air tuner. Here’s the commercial product:

The dual figure on the face of the ‘021 Patent shows a perspective view and front view of the design:

U.S. Patent No. D1,022,025:  Legere’s Reed Case

This post is about a subject near and dear to my heart: saxophone reeds. Legere is a Canadian company that makes woodwind reeds and accessories.

Last month, Legere was issued a design patent on one of its reed cases.  U.S. Patent No. D1,022,025 claims the ornamental design for the reed case as shown below (among other variations).

The embodiment of FIG. 15 most closely resembles the reed case I found for sale on eBay:

Unlike utility patents, which protect functional features (how the invention works), design patents protect purely ornamental or aesthetic features of a device.

I gave up using reed cases a while ago in favor of small Nalgene water bottles.  Though they require regular cleaning and freshening, I find keeping the reeds wet improves my saxophone sound a lot and extends the life of the reeds.

The Hybrid Intelligence Work: Can a Layer of Creative Human Intelligence Make Your AI-Generated Work Protectable?

Creative works, whether written, designed, or musical – are not copyrightable if generated through artificial intelligence (AI).  This is because only human authors are eligible for copyright protection (remember the monkey selfie?). 

What can you do, then, if you feed prompts into a large language model (LLM) like ChatGPT to generate an original story, graphic design, song, or other kind of work?  There may be ways to obtain some remuneration from the work by making it available for download on third-party platforms.  However, as a work with no human author, and therefore no copyright protection, there is nothing to prevent others from copying, displaying, re-distributing, or otherwise exploiting the work for their own personal gain.

Unless there are major changes to the law of copyright, we have to forget about protecting the AI-generated work as is.  But what if you were to make a small, but substantial, change or addition to the work spit out by the LLM?

A creative work that uses a prior work as its raw material and contains changes to that work or adds a sufficient amount of new material is called a derivative work.  If the original work is copyrighted, the author seeking to create a derivative work would need permission from the owner of the copyright in the original work to add to or alter it. 

However, derivative works also can be created from works that are in the public domain.  The most common example of a public domain work is a work whose copyright has expired.  Now that we have works created by AI (and the occasional non-human primate), I think it’s accurate to categorize them as public domain works.

In other words, works generated by AI don’t enter the public domain after a lifetime of copyright protection; they are born into the public domain.

Oh, and here’s the nice thing about a derivative work:  you can get a copyright on it.

But the copyright protects only the additions or changes to the original work, not the elements of the original work.  So, how could you copyright an AI-generated work, and why would you do it?

First, you feed the prompts you want into the LLM – ChatGPT, or whichever one you use – and the AI spits out a work.  Let’s say you’re a composer and the work is a song.  But at this point, the song is merely a public domain work exploitable by anyone.

You’d need to change or add to that song to make it a protectable derivative work of the AI’s original song.  So you compose a new part for the song – vocals, a countermelody, a bridge, and/or a bass line – and using any recording software, you add that new part to the AI-generated song.  Assuming some originality to your new part(s), you now have a hybrid track  – the original AI song plus your new part(s) – eligible for copyright protection as a derivative work.

Let’s call this new kind of derivative work – a hybrid work partially generated by artificial intelligence and partially created by human intelligence – a Hybrid Intelligence Work (HIW).

You file a copyright application with the U.S. Copyright Office and upload the hybrid track to the Copyright Office website with the application.  The application requires that you specify the pre-existing material and the new material, so you provide that information, and you should be able to get a copyright registration for your HIW.

Now, when you release the track yourself and/or via a music streaming service, if someone copies the file, tries to distribute it, etc., that would infringe your copyright in the derivative work. 

Let’s go one step further to illustrate the significance of the HIW.  Maybe you label your track to indicate that it was generated, at least in part, by AI.  There may be some people out there savvy enough to know  that AI-generated works are public domain (and as time goes on and more AI-generated works are distributed, this should slowly become common knowledge).

Even someone armed with this knowledge would have a tough time legally exploiting your HIW because the track consists of an inseparable (or very difficult to separate) amalgam of AI-generated public domain elements and human-created copyrighted elements.  That, in effect, protects your hybrid track from copying because the only way someone can feasibly copy it is to take the whole track, which would constitute infringement of your copyright in the HIW.

I understand that it is possible to isolate parts of a recording, but typically you need access to the original multi-track recording or sophisticated software to do it.  Even if someone had the software and wanted to separate out your copyrighted elements, it might not be obvious which elements of the mix those are.

So, while you can’t currently copyright your AI-generated work, adding a dash of creative human intelligence could result in a copyrightable Hybrid Intelligence Work.